architecture

Quick Review

Well-structured architectural decision framework with clear file organization and selective reading guidance. The SKILL.md provides an excellent content map directing users to relevant files for specific tasks (context discovery, trade-offs, patterns, examples). Strong on structure with logical separation of concerns across files. The description adequately conveys when to use the skill. Task knowledge appears comprehensive across referenced files covering requirements analysis, ADR templates, and pattern selection. Novelty is moderate - while architectural decision-making is valuable, much of this guidance (ADRs, trade-off analysis, pattern selection) could be handled by a capable CLI agent with sufficient prompting, though the structured framework does provide efficiency gains and consistency. The validation checklist and core principles add practical value. Minor improvement areas: more explicit workflow steps in main file and clearer differentiation of when this skill provides unique value over direct agent reasoning.